Praxis is seldom welcome at the doorstep of musical theory but it is precisely the everyday practicalities of making music that concern Nikolaus Harnoncourt. His early recordings and performances with the revolutionary Concentus musicus Wien began proving in the 1960s that scholarship and musical pleasure could join hands. Now the rebirth of Teldec's Das Alte Werk series offers the chance to reevaluate the Harnoncourt legacy and to consider the future of music first heard long ago. The popularity of old music among record collectors owes a huge debt to Das Alte Werk. The series, which had its first release in 1958, pioneered the early music movement in recordings. In 1963, the then little-known Harnoncourt made his recording debut with Music from the Court of Mannheim, the first recording ever of music performed in period style on authentic instruments. Harnoncourt went on to make more than two hundred recordings for the series with the Concentus musicus Wien. The label included contributions by other luminaries of the early music movement as well, including Gustav Leonhardt, Frans Bruggen, and Japp Schröder.
This year, the legendary label is being relaunched in style, making available such gems as Karl Richter's Bach cantatas and the Pro Cantione Antiqua's revelatory recordings of old English songs. Not every recording is old, however; among the brightest new groups to join the roster is Il Giardino Armonico, Italy's first authentic-instrument ensemble and the hottest Vivaldi interpreters since Harnoncourt shocked the world with his Four Seasons about thirty years ago.
Das Alte Werk, by fortunate accident as much as by visionary design, has been a gathering point for congenial musical minds opposed to dogma. Now on compact disc, the Teldec series brings together ground-breaking recordings of the 1960s and early '70s, like Harnoncourt's versions of the Christmas Oratorio by Bach and the Messiah by Handel, with his 1993 first-time releases on the cutting edge in Baroque recordings. "What we have to discover," says Frans Bruggen, another pillar of the record label, "is what the composer wanted, and not what he had to be satisfied with."
This goes far beyond the misguided good intentions of those who would attempt to reproduce what the composer actually heard. There are, to be sure, several ways to bring music to life. The process involves an interesting conflict of approaches, not least because of the clever piece of sophistry implied in the project of reconstructing the past: Even if it were possible to reproduce faithfully every detail of a musical performance, it would be impossible to reproduce the way in which it was heard. The truth of a work of music lies in the meeting of its performance and its reception by
...