|
|
|
| Current Issue |
|
|
| Resources |
|
|
|
Bad Times for Good Hearts
| Article
# : |
14209 |
|
|
Section : |
BOOK WORLD
|
| Issue
Date : |
7 / 1988 |
4,346 Words |
| Author
: |
James J. Thompson. Jr.
James J. Thompson. Jr., is the book review editor of the New
Oxford Review. He has written three books: Tried As by Fire:
Southern Baptists and the Religious Controversies of the 1920s
(1982); Christian Classics Revisited (1983); and Fleeing the
Whore of Babylon: A Modern Conversion Story (1986). He has
coedited The Southern Essays of Richard M. Weaver (1987). |
GOOD HEARTS
Reynolds Price
New York: Atheneum, 1988
275 pages, $18.95
Duckness used to be fairly easy to spot. If it had feathers like a duck, waddled like a duck, and quacked like a duck, then the irrefragable rules of logic dictated that it was a duck. Southern novelists seem determined to deny their duckness. Lure twenty of them to a literary conference (large quantities of cheap bourbon will usually do the trick), and at least nineteen of them will obdurately refuse to be introduced as a Southern novelist. Why disclaim your duckness when it is an old and honorable condition? If a man or woman, born and raised in the South, sits down at a typewriter, fills page upon page with words about characters who dwell in the South, the result is a Southern novel, right? Wrong! shriek the authors: A duck is not always a duck.
What is going on? To begin with, the king of that particular jungle known as Southern fiction is indisputably William Faulkner. His roar tends, by comparison, to reduce everyone else to a squeaky meow. This was not always true, for at the height of the "Southern Renaissance," that tidal wave of novelmaking that swept the South from, say, 1925 to 1955, Faulkner faced a raft of competitors for the throne. Literary critics (and what Gore Vidal derides as "book-chat people") discerned enough common themes and shared regional markings to warrant calling these writers "Southern." Those so designated did not protest. Who wouldn't be proud to be numbered in the surge of creativity that boosted the South to preeminence in the world of letters?
By establishing himself as the epitome of the Southern novelist, Faulkner erected for succeeding writers not only a model to emulate, but a goal seemingly impossible to attain. By the 1950s a curious phenomenon emerged: Young Southerners published Faulknerian novels while simultaneously denying that they were Southern Writers. As the critic Louis Rubin put it, "getting out from under Faulkner" became the enduring problem for Southerners. By repudiating the regional tag--by disowning their duckness--they hoped to obviate the inevitable comparison with the master.
Other Ducks and the Problem of Duckness
If some ducks wish to deny their duckness, others have been transformed into swans. To wit: Young novelists in the South today can
...
Read Full Article
Look for this article in Ask.com
|
|
